Butterscotch Chocolate Chunk Candy Cookies

by spiceaholic on October 29, 2016

UntitledI can’t stop eating these cookies! If you’re in the mood for cookies full of chocolate chunks, candy and butterscotch, you have to give these a try.

Some fun facts about these cookies:

  1. They don’t have eggs in them – perfect for those with egg allergies and those of you who want to be able to eat cookie dough without fears of salmonella
  2. They do contain Greek yogurt – SURPRISE!  The yogurt takes the place of the eggs in these cookies. I used Stonyfield Organic plain nonfat Greek yogurt.
  3. They are loaded with all sorts of deliciousness – oatmeal, chocolate chunks, butterscotch chips, and UNREAL candy-coated milk chocolates. If you’re unfamiliar with UNREAL candy, check out their story here, but their products contain  non-GMO, fair-trade/ethically sourced, and gluten-free ingredients.

As part of this month’s challenge with the Stonyfield Organic Clean Plate Club, I received samples of UNREAL Candy’s dark chocolate peanut butter cups, dark chocolate almond butter cups, and candy coated milk chocolates. I was curious about the candy coated milk chocolates, as I’ve seen the other two at stores here.  The candy coating color comes from natural sources such as beetroot and carrot juices, which I liked.  Once I tasted them, I realize they reminded me a lot of Smarties, which are a British brand of candy coated milk chocolates that I absolutely love and cannot find that easily in the States. Needless to say, I’ll be buying more of the UNREAL version to get my Smarties fix!

I decided cookies were the perfect vehicle for showcasing these candies. I used this recipe as my inspiration and then tweaked based on what I like to put into my cookies. I really like the idea of incorporating Greek yogurt into these cookies -it’s so unexpected but you really don’t notice it. I may have to try this trick in other cookie recipes as well!


*Disclosure: Stonyfield Organic provided me with coupons for their yogurt and compensated me for this post as part of their Clean Plate Club. UNREAL provided me with samples of their chocolate candy as part of this month’s campaign. All opinions are my own.


Butterscotch Chocolate Chunk Candy Cookies


1/2 cup granulated sugar

1/2 cup packed light brown sugar

1/2 cup butter, softened

1/2 cup plain non-fat Greek yogurt

2 tsp. vanilla extract OR 1 tsp. vanilla extract and 1 tsp. vanilla and butter nut extract

1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour

1/2 cup oatmeal (old-fashioned rolled)

1/2 tsp. ground cinnamon

1/2 tsp. baking soda

1/2 tsp. salt

2 cups combined your choice of add-ins  (chocolate chips/chunks, butterscotch chip, candy-coated chocolate candy, etc.)


Preheat oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit.  Line 2 baking sheets with parchment paper.

In a large bowl, cream together the sugars and butter until fluffy. Add in Greek yogurt and vanilla extract and stir to combine.

In a separate bowl, combine the flour, oatmeal, cinnamon, baking soda, and salt.  Add into the butter/sugar/yogurt mixture slowly until incorporated.

Mix in the chocolate chips/candies.  Chill cookie dough in fridge for about 10 minutes.

Use an ice-cream scoop to drop cookie dough onto the cookie sheets, keeping cookies 2 inches apart. These will be large mounds of dough, I got about 7-8 per cookie sheet.

Bake for about 15-17 minutes or until the edges begin to turn golden brown. Take out of oven and let cool for a few minutes before transferring to wire racks.


Crusty Oven Fried Chicken Thighs

Fried chicken is easily one of my favorite foods. The crunchy fried crust is the best part in my opinion. All your fried chicken skins are belong to me.

However, I am a huge scaredy-cat when it comes to frying stuff.  So we usually end up hitting the drive-thru or grocery store deli for ours, more times than I care to admit (ahem).  I’ve tried making it in the oven before, but given that I’m usually using skinless chicken and baking it, let’s just say it’s not the same.

But have you seen the picture at the top of this post? I think that looks pretty respectable! I tried something a little different this time: dipping the chicken thighs in beaten egg and then dredging in PANCAKE MIX. Oh and using melted butter to coat the baking dish and on top of the chicken.  But yes, pancake mix!

The folks at Krusteaz, who are known for their easy to use baking mixes, offered to send me a selection of their pancake and muffin mixes, as well as a few other goodies so that I could play around with them and share them with you all. Now that we are kinda heading into fall weather, I was really tempted to make some baked doughnuts or some cookies, but my savory tooth won out this time – plus I’ve been craving some comfort food like fried chicken lately.

I’m no stranger to Krusteaz mixes – I used to buy their fat-free brownie mix back during my early Weight Watchers days. For someone like me who hates all the meticulous measuring and fiddly-ness of baking, these mixes are a godsend. Besides making the mixes as intended, it’s fun to use them in different ways.

Back to this chicken. I know using pancake mix to bread chicken isn’t the most novel idea and it’s been done before, but it was new to me and a way to think outside of the pancake mix box. The combo of beaten egg and pancake mix gave me that fried chicken crust that I miss when I make oven fried chicken. And let’s be honest, the butter definitely helped. I usually used cooking spray so while it was healthier, you lose some of the yum factor.  Since the pancake mix was a little sweet, I just added more seasonings. Feel free to adjust the amounts in the recipe below to suit your tastes, or play around with your own combination.

The folks at Krusteaz want to give one of you a chance to get creative and experiment with their pancake and muffin mixes as part of their Say It With Krusteaz campaign.  One reader will receive a generous sampling (2 each) of their buttermilk, pumpkin spice, and blueberry pancake mixes, their pumpkin spice and cranberry orange muffin mixes, as well as an oven mitt, tote bag, and a selfie stick!

Say it with Krusteaz

How nice is that? That’s plenty of mixes to help you create something new!

All you have to do to win this giveaway is to leave a comment telling me how you would use pancake or muffin mix in a creative way.  I might even try out one of your ideas!

Giveaway is limited to U.S. residents age 18 and over. Giveaway runs from Sunday, October 23rd, 2016 through 10pm EST Friday, October 28th, 2016. Once I’ve selected a winner, I will email you to get your contact info, so make sure you enter an email address when leaving a comment (it won’t show up in the comment). Winner has 48 hours to reply or else I will have to select another winner.

UPDATE: Congrats, Judith! You won all those mixes! Please check your email!

*Disclosure: Krusteaz provided me with the items described above. I did not receive any compensation and am not obligated to post a positive review. Any opinions are my own. Krusteaz is providing the prize for the winner of the giveaway.

Crusty Oven Fried Chicken Thighs

Crusty Oven Fried Chicken Thighs


2/3 cup buttermilk pancake mix

2 eggs, beaten

2 tbsp. butter

1 tsp. ground black pepper

1 tsp. seasoned salt

1/4 tsp. ground white pepper

1 tsp. dried thyme

1 tsp. garlic powder

1/2 tsp. paprika

1 lb. boneless skinless chicken thighs


Preheat oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. Spread half of the melted butter in a 9×13 inch glass baking dish and set aside.

Combine pancake mix and all spices in a shallow dish.

Dip both sides of each chicken thigh in beaten egg and then dredge into seasoned pancake mix, making sure to coat both sides thoroughly.  Lay flat in baking dish. Repeat for each thigh. Pour remaining melted butter over tops of chicken thighs.

Bake for approximately 30 minutes, or until cooked, turning thighs over halfway through.



Salted Chocolate Caramel Bars – Bake a Difference with OXO for Cookies for Kids’ Cancer and Dorie Greenspan

September 20, 2016

Say it with me: salted chocolate caramel bars. With a chocolate shortbread crust.  What is not to like about these? You guys know I am not a very confident baker, so why on earth did I decide to attempt to make chocolate shortbread and salted chocolate caramel?  Especially with a 13 month-old running around like […]

Read the full article →

Easy Chicken Badami

August 30, 2016

Yogurt and almond butter.  In a chicken dish.  Bet you didn’t see that one coming! But it totally works. This month’s challenge through the Stonyfield Organic Clean Plate Club was to use their yogurt and Justin’s Nut Butter in a recipe. I’ve tried some of their different nut butters before and enjoy them, but was […]

Read the full article →

Bengali-Style Chinese Noodles

July 11, 2016

This is a comfort food dish from my childhood that I love even to this day. It would make appearances on potluck dinner tables, a welcome reprieve to all the traditional Bengali dishes like pullao, korma, dal, vegetables, various beef/chicken/fish curries. I also remember eating it for lunch with my cousins when we’d go visit […]

Read the full article →

Chocolate Orange Protein Smoothie

May 31, 2016

Ahhh, it’s been getting warmer and warmer lately, which means it’s smoothie season! They really are such an easy way to get in some much-needed fruits and veggies, that I should do them year-round. More importantly, with a newly-mobile 9 month-old who loves crawling everywhere and hates sitting still, I need a fast option for […]

Read the full article →

Easy Dark Chocolate Oatmeal Squares with Yogurt Berry Glaze

February 14, 2016

So let’s talk about these oatmeal squares. After I had Baby N last August, I was all about wanting to try making lactation cookies so that I could theoretically boost my milk supply. I tried a mix I bought of Amazon, and it was disgusting. I tried making some energy bites and they were meh. […]

Read the full article →

The Best Gift I’ve Ever Received

December 30, 2015

Happy holidays to those of you who are still reading here! I know I’ve pretty much dropped off the radar this past year, but taking care of a baby does tend to take up all of my time!  And let’s be honest, the past couple years I wasn’t posting much anyway due to work. I […]

Read the full article →

Red Lentil and Potato Cakes with Harissa Yogurt Sauce

September 29, 2015

I’m a bit proud of myself for making these.  Sure, making potato cakes isn’t that hard to do, so why am I making a big deal about it? Let’s just say my time has been otherwise occupied recently. Meet Baby N! He made his debut in August. I think he’s a pretty good reason! Somehow […]

Read the full article →

Tenderest Cardamom Pancakes

May 29, 2015

I’ve happily eaten yogurt for many years, but it has only been within the past few that I’ve transitioned from being merely a yogurt consumer to a yogurt user as well.  You see, it took me a while to appreciate how versatile yogurt is and how it can be used in so many different ways. […]

Read the full article →